The G5RV is a 102 ft dipole fed with ~30 ft of parallel line plus coax the rest of the way to the shack. The ZS6BKW is a 92 ft dipole fed with 40' of parallel line plus coax the rest of the way to the shack. Both antennas need a 1:1 choke-balun at the BALanced twinlead to UNbalanced coax junction.
The ZS6BKW is not a perfect antenna. The SWR on 80m is too high and the 40 ft ladder line matching section is a little too long on 17m and a little too short on 10m putting resonance outside of the priviledges of the technician license. The standard ZS6BKW is mismatched on 30m and 15m and requires a major change in the length of the ladder-line to achieve system resonance on those bands. Here's what the standard ZS6BKW SWR's looked like before modifications.
With a few modifications, the following measured SWR's were obtained from the modified ZS6BKW.
Frequency, impedance, SWR, series capacitor, New SWR
3.60 MHz, 14+j49 ohms, 7.1:1, -j49 = 902 pF, 3.6:1
3.70 MHz, 22+j80 ohms, 8.4:1, -j80 = 538 pF, 2.3:1
3.80 MHz, 34+j116 ohms, 10:1, -j116 = 361 pF, 1.5:1
3.87 MHz, 50+j147 ohms, 10.5:1, -j147 = 280 pF, 1:1
3.90 MHz, 59+j162 ohms, 10.8:1, -j162 = 252 pF, 1.2:1
Reasonable SWRs were obtained centered around 3.845 MHz using a 500 pF series doorknob capacitor - illustrated in the following block diagram.
Since the reactance of the 500 pF capacitor decreases with frequency, it can be left in the circuit on all of the higher frequency bands. For instance, it has almost no effect on 10m where the reactance is only -j11 ohms. Here are the SWR curves for 80m for the standard ZS6BKW and with various values of series capacitors in the circuit.
For a lower resonant frequency, the following circuit resulted in an SWR of 1.2:1 on 3.83 MHz.
The parallel capacitor is switched in for 80m operation and switched out for all the higher frequency bands. Switching a capacitor in and out of a circuit located at the coax/twinlead junction on an antenna like the ZS6BKW is a challenge that depends on the particular installation. Worst case it can be done with a remote relay. Is the parallel capacitor worth the results? Following is an SWR graph with and without the parallel capacitor. If the capacitors are switched seperately, an SWR of 3:1 or less is obtained from 3.54 to 3.69 MHz with only the parallel capacitor - making that a good configuration for 80m CW/DATA operation. The series capacitor only configuration results in an SWR less than 3:1 for 3.72-3.87 MHz. With both caps switched in, the SWR is less than 3:1 for 3.7-3.9 MHz with a near-perfect match on 3.83 MHz. That's about 72% coverage of 80m depending on which capacitors are switched in or out. Who says a ZS6BKW doesn't work well on 80m?
Hopefully, something in this article will be helpful to hams wishing to adjust their ZS6BKW's resonant frequency or use their ZS6BKW on 80m while reducing coax and tuner losses. Unfortunately, without doing something at the antenna feedpoint, there is no way to reduce losses in the ladder-line matching section which on 80m, can be in the ballpark of 2 dB. Open-wire feedline would probably reduce those feedline losses compared to the windowed ladder-line.